PDA

View Full Version : Massive failure of disclosure by writer brings Seattle Weekly story into question



bijou
07-25-2011, 11:45 AM
Seattle Weekly published a remarkable cover story last week. Over the course of more than 6,000 words, it made the argument that true crime author Ann Rule made a series of mistakes and false conclusions in her book, Heart Full of Lies.

The book tells to story of the shooting death of Oregon pilot Chris Northon. He was killed by his wife, Liysa. Seattle Weekly’s story argued that she “was failed by her original lawyer, an overzealous district attorney, and Rule, who claimed that Liysa was not the battered wife she’d portrayed herself to be, but rather a sociopath who’d concocted tales of abuse as a justification for shooting her husband.”

The author of the piece is Rick Swart, the editor and publisher of the Wallowa County Chieftain, a community newspaper in the area where the crime took place. He pitched the piece to Seattle Weekly and they published it last week.

The problem is Swart committed a massive failure of disclosure. Here’s how Seattle Weekly’s Caleb Hannan explains the issue in his editor’s note, which is here and was added to the top of the cover story:

What Swart failed to reveal to us is that he’s now engaged to Liysa. ...link (http://www.regrettheerror.com/2011/07/25/massive-failure-of-disclosure-by-writer-brings-seattle-weekly-cover-story-into-question/)

Odysseus
07-25-2011, 12:30 PM
And, of course, the reporter's response was a variation on the old "our bias doesn't factor into our stories" line of BS:


It’s a freelance piece first of all. I’m selling you a product. So it’s not like you’re my boss and you need to know my personal life. My background is in community newspapers where we write about people we know, people we have relationships with, all the time. We don’t have the luxury of big staffs. So we’re not as able to have those arms-lengths relationships I guess…I’m willing to have all this fall squarely on my shoulder.

Yeah, there's a bit of a difference between posting about someone that you know in the community and your fiancee. I'm just surprised that the other paper bothered following up. After all, George Stephanopolous and Chris Matthews report on political stories about people that they were employed by or with whom they have personal relationships, and nobody in the MSM questions their objectivity. What's the difference between being in bed with your fiancee and writing about her and being in bed with the entire Democratic Party and reporting on them?