PDA

View Full Version : Pat Buchanan attacked by Neo-cons



Molon Labe
06-13-2008, 12:45 PM
Pat's latest book has caused quite a controversy...he's even got some in the Neo con camp up in arms.

http://www.townhall.com/columnists/PatrickJBuchanan/2008/06/13/the_good_war_and_the_terrible_peace



The 'Good War' and the Terrible Peace
by Patrick J. Buchanan


In attacking my book Churchill, Hitler and 'The Unnecessary War': How Britain Lost Its Empire and the West Lost the World, Victor Davis Hanson, the court historian of the neoconservatives, charges me with "rewriting ... facts" and showing "ingratitude" to American and British soldiers who fought World Wars I and II.

Both charges are false, and transparently so.

Hanson cites not a single fact I got wrong and ignores the fact that the book is dedicated to my mother's four brothers who fought in World War II. Moreover, the book begins by celebrating the greatness of the British nation and heroism of its soldier-sons.

Did Hanson even read it?

The focus of "The Unnecessary War" is on the colossal blunders by British statesmen that reduced Britain from the greatest empire since Rome into an island dependency of the United States in three decades. It is a cautionary tale, written for America, which is treading the same path Britain trod in the early 20th century.

Hanson agrees the Versailles Treaty of 1919 was "flawed," but says Germany had it coming, for the harsh peace the Germans imposed on France in 1871 and Russia in 1918.

Certainly, the amputation of Alsace-Lorraine by Bismarck's Germany was a blunder that engendered French hatred and a passion for revenge. But does Teutonic stupidity in 1871 justify British stupidity in 1919?

Is that what history teaches, Hanson?

In 1918, Germany accepted an armistice on Wilson's 14 Points, laid down her arms and surrendered her High Seas Fleet.

Yet, once disarmed, Germany was subjected to a starvation blockade, denied the right to fish in the Baltic Sea, and saw all her colonies and private property therein confiscated by British, French and Japanese imperialists, in naked violation of Wilson's 14 Points.

Germans, Austrians and Hungarians by the millions were then consigned to Belgium, France, Italy, Serbia, Czechoslovakia, Romania, Poland and Lithuania, in violation of the principle of self-determination.

Germany was sliced in half, dismembered, disarmed, saddled with unpayable debt .. .

Goldwater
06-13-2008, 03:17 PM
Eventually World War 2 might have forced the allies into the game, however World War 1 was quite possibly the most pointless war in history, and the fact that out of it's ashes rose WW2 makes it even worse.

Molon Labe
06-13-2008, 03:59 PM
Eventually World War 2 might have forced the allies into the game, however World War 1 was quite possibly the most pointless war in history, and the fact that out of it's ashes rose WW2 makes it even worse.

Absolutely. I was taught years ago that it was essentially a land grab. Another reason why Wilson is arguably the worst president in history.