Results 1 to 3 of 3
  1. #1 Snuff Civilization (Crazy Lib Wants Women, Children To Die) 
    Snuff Civilization
    by Derrick Jensen

    Had somebody snuffed civilization in its multiple cradles, the Middle East would probably still be forested, as would Greece, Italy, and North Africa. Lions would probably still patrol southern Europe. The peoples of the region would quite possibly still live in traditional communal ways, and thus would be capable of feeding themselves in a still-fecund landscape.

    Fast forward a few hundred years and we can say the same in Europe. Somehow stop the Greeks and Romans, and the indigenous people of Gaul, Spain, Germany probably still survive. Wolves might howl in England. Great auks might nest in France, providing year-round food for the humans who live there.

    Salmon might run in more than token numbers up the Seine. The Rhine is almost undoubtedly clean. The continent is forested. Many of the cultures are matrifocal. Many are peaceful.

    Had someone brought down civilization before 1492, the Arawaks would probably still live peacefully in the Caribbean. Indians would live in ancient forests all along the Eastern seaboard, along with bison, marten, fisher. North, Central, and South America would be ecologically and culturally intact. The people would probably have, as always, plenty to eat.

    Had someone brought down civilization before the slave trade took hold, 100 million Africans would not have been sacrificed on that particular altar of economic production. Native cultures might still live untraumatized on their own land all across that continent. There probably would be, as there always was, plenty to eat.

    If someone had brought down civilization one hundred and fifty years ago, those who came after probably could still eat passenger pigeons and Eskimo curlews. They could surely eat bison and pronghorn antelope. They could undoubtedly eat salmon, cod, lobster. The people who came after would not have had to worry about dioxin, radiation poisoning, organochloride carcinogens, or the extreme weather and ecological flux that characterize global warming. They would not have had to worry about escaped genetically-engineered plants and animals. There probably would have been, as almost always, plenty to eat.

    If civilization lasts another one or two hundred years, will the people then say of us, “Why did they not take it down?” Will they be as furious with us as I am with those who came before and stood by? I could very well hear those people who come after saying, “If they had taken it down, we would still have earthworms to feed the soil. We would have redwoods, and we would have oaks in California. We would still have frogs. We would still have other amphibians. I am starving because there are no salmon in the river, and you allowed the salmon to be killed so rich people could have cheap electricity for aluminum smelters. God damn you. God damn you all.”

    I know someone whose brother demolishes buildings. The trick, he says, is to position the charges precisely so the building collapses in place, and doesn’t take out the surroundings. It seems to me that this is what we must do: position the charges so that civilization collapses in on itself, and takes out as little life as possible on its way down.

    Part of the task of the rest of this exploration is to discover what form those charges will take, and where to put them.

    The past few weeks I’ve been in crisis. I’m scared. Scared of the implications of this work. Scared to articulate what I know in my heart is necessary, and even more scared to help bring it about. I mean, we’re talking about taking down civilization here.

    Last night I was at my mom’s eating dinner and watching a little March Madness—the NCAA basketball tournament—and I kept thinking, as I watched UNC-Wilmington hold off USC in overtime after blowing a nineteen-point lead, a variant of the question my friend asked about what right I have to not let people live in cities. There are hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of people having fun watching these games. They’re not trying to exploit anyone. They’re not trying to kill the planet. What right do I have to so alter their lives?

    I’m not saying there would never be games again, because the lives of traditional indigenous peoples the world over are far more full of leisure and play than ours. I’m just saying that bringing down civilization would cause substantive changes in the way these people spend their time. And they may not—evidently they do not—want to change.

    The answer came to me today. It’s the same answer I gave my friend, which is that I think it’s the wrong question. The question is: what right do all of these people have to destroy the lives of others by their very lifestyle?
    More at the link. The take home message from this guy that I see is this: being an illiterate savage living in a pristine wilderness is just fine by me since I, personally, won't be sold into slavery, raped, beaten, die in childbirth, or be denied food and shelter when my sexual utility disappears. :mad:

    Beck is evidently talking about this idiot today.

    [rul=]Alternative Mag[/url]
    Reply With Quote  

  2. #2  
    Power CUer noonwitch's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Warren, MI
    He's of the "noble savage" mentality.

    It's always fun to point out to people like him that:

    1. native americans ate meat, wore leather, and fought wars with each other long before Columbus, or even the Vikings visited North America.

    2. african tribal leaders sold captives of their wars to white slavers

    3. The spread of christianity is one of the primary factors in ending societal acceptance of slavery in the western world.

    There's no fantasy past world of unspoiled beauty before civilization. They might not have had air pollution or contaminated rivers and lakes, but people had short lifespans, disease was rampant and women died in childbirth in numbers we would consider completely unacceptable by our standards.
    Reply With Quote  

  3. #3  
    Senior Ape Articulate_Ape's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    NJ, Exit Only
    Did that guy ever read a book? Civilizations have been "snuffed" numerous times throughout history and let me tell you there were no communes filled with flower-haired hippies holding hands and singing in the forest as song birds landed on their shoulders. Nope, it was not pretty. If starvation, the elements, or disease didn't kill you, there were roving bands of folks who would happily dispatch you and yours to get whatever near nothing you had.

    What a friggin' dolt.
    "The efforts of the government alone will never be enough. In the end the people must choose and the people must help themselves" ~ JFK; from his famous inauguration speech (What Democrats sounded like before today's neo-Liberals hijacked that party)
    Reply With Quote  

Posting Permissions
  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts