I've been a loyal Lancome make up wearer for many, many years.
I recently tried makeup by Kat VonSomething(girl Jesse James fooled around with when married to Sandra Bullock) from Sephora and I am VERY, very impressed. I bought her foundation which makes my skin look flawless, love it. Bought an Eye shadow palette in soft colors. It goes on smooth and lasts for hours. Their shadow is well pigmented so you don't need a lot. Mascara is good, nothing stands out from other brands, but doesn't clump.
(Sorry about pic quality, used my daughter's iTouch)