Results 1 to 8 of 8
  1. #1 The 'Closed Circle' of the Arab 
    LTC Member Odysseus's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    FT Belvoir, VA
    Posts
    15,638
    Several years ago, I read David Pryce-Jones' book, The Closed Circle: An Explanation of the Arabs, and found it to be a superb guide to dealing with Arab culture (and, by extension, Islamic culture, which is based on the norms of Arab culture). The following article provides an excellent summary of the book. Enjoy.


    January 13, 2013 The 'Closed Circle' of the Arab

    By Glenn Fairman


    Viewed through the prism of the West, which draws its sustenance from the twin fountains of Athens and Jerusalem, the character and plight of Arab existence has been viewed as romantic, tragic, and uniquely foreign to our sensibilities. The fact that its spirit is wholly antithetical to ours has been a point of contention between advocates of multiculturalism and those jealous of the West's rich patrimony.

    That the Arabs are a civilization deeply stratified along lines of family, clan, and tribe is a fundamental observation. If, however, one overlays the Arab's psychological predisposition to the "power/challenge," money-favoring, careerist, and "shame/honor" dynamics of culture, we in the West cannot hope for any genuine alliances based upon anything more solid than contingencies of transitory mutual advantage. Moreover, the liberal West must come finally to the stark realization that the Arab world is a zone where democracy and human rights, as we view them, cannot flourish, because such a Western abstraction cannot set its tendrils down in the flinty earth of unenlightened self-interest. In the realm of the Middle East, politics and prestige are as they have always been -- the currency of a zero-sum game.

    In the late 1980s, David Pryce-Jones authored a book entitled The Closed Circle, in which he interpreted the psychic rudiments of the Arab weltanschauung -- and unless one understands this mentality on its own terms, the Occidental mind will never gain traction either in negotiations or in bridging the gulf between civilizations -- to the West's own peril. Although it was written several decades ago, no other book has ever offered a convincing understanding of the Arab's rationale in decision-making and conduct. Without understanding the dynamic of the Arabic "power/challenge" struggle, their entire culture appears to the West to be one of madness instead of intense and never-ending calculation for superiority and honor at the expense of anything that even approaches what the West views as political stability, human rights, and moral virtue.

    In the light of such cultural dynamics, we err gravely when we rely upon projecting the suppositions of Western values into the cauldron of the Middle East. As a case in point, the Western powers have naively sought to reduce the Palestinian question to one of real estate and the contractual exigency of a settlement where give-and-take is an implicit axiom. However, undergirding the prospects of such an agreement are the complications of the "shame/honor" dialectic and the Islamic tenet that once a land has been claimed for Allah, it belongs in perpetuity to the faith. Therein, the struggle between Arab and Jew is fraught with the contagion of shame and the resulting loss of honor at having been bested by the loathsome Jew. If one throws into the mix the military humiliations of the last century at the hands of Israel and the Western Powers, it becomes readily apparent that the Arab psyche that glorifies domination and revenge cannot countenance such a transaction, especially now that the Star of Islam is ascending on the world's stage.

    The Arab world and its Islamic worldview have proven inconsistent with the tenets of modernity and free intellectual exchange because of the former's inability to both wield and relinquish power and to brook dissent. Since the fall of the Ottoman Empire at the close of WWl and the creation of the Middle Eastern nations out of whole cloth, the orderly transfer of power in Arab States is practically a null set. Instead, we see the ancient motifs of "power challenging" occurring again and again -- actuated through conspiracy and temporary coalitions that are usually stratified along tribal loyalties. No sooner, however, than one dog reaches the top of the heap does a new round of murmuring arise through those participants who feel that they are being shortchanged or disrespected through the money-favoring nexus -- proving true the old adage quoted in a recent column that "an Arab cannot be bought, only rented."

    Without institutional mores set in place in which power devolves peacefully and without rancor, ruthless violence has been the only means by which power is maintained or usurped in the Arab world. Despite the window dressing of political rhetoric that promises freedom and change following the downfall of a corrupt regime, no amount of ideological overlay ever changes the deep-set cultural barbarism in which only the names change at the top while the losers are purged and the weak brutally fleeced.

    For the suffering millions who have endured life under Islamic theocracy or Pan-Arabic Socialism, the song has ever remained the same. The West, and in particular the American administrations of the past century, have been played like proverbial fiddles because in failing to understand the Arab consciousness and its animating interests, they believe, like all good liberals believe, that all cultures and moralities are commensurate and therefore rational and receptive to calculations of long term expedience. By not heeding the "power/challenge dialectic," we fail to understand what motivates the manifest treachery and butchery in the Middle Eastern arc -- either from paranoid dictators or in the rising host of new tyrannical carnivores who wait in the wings in hopes of one day being given the opportunity to strike and therein wield the reins of unmixed power.

    By ignoring the "shame/honor" duality, we fail to grasp the subterranean darkness that motivates the honor-killings of daughters or apostates who "blacken the face" of the Arab family. In this perverse milieu, the shedding of "guilty" blood is the only manner in which a face can again "be whitened." As a tribute to the cultural gulf that separates our sensibilities, it is incomprehensible to us that this barbaric filial vengeance is not only deemed justice, but indeed morally laudable in the twisted logic of the Arab's exaggerated sense of pride.

    The great schizophrenia of the Arab mind must wrestle with two mutually exclusive thoughts: that Arabs are the most blessed of the earth while in fact being the most wretched. Unable to reconcile these twin polarities and in turn incapable of the self-reflection necessary for a civilization's enlightened Reformation to occur, a host of scapegoats are necessary in the form of Jews, infidels, and imperialists who are persistently denying the chosen people their proper station. Until this transformation occurs, the remedy for the Arab soul will be "more Islam" and an unending return to filial bloodshed, intrigue, and unrelenting tyranny both between man and woman and between regime and subject. Having proved the biblical adage that "the dog returns to its own vomit," the closed circle of the Arab heart retains a sickness that is never cured and a lesson that is forever unlearned.


    Page Printed from: http://www.americanthinker.com/artic..._the_arab.html at January 14, 2013 - 03:31:37 PM CST
    --Odysseus
    Sic Hacer Pace, Para Bellum.

    Before you can do things for people, you must be the kind of man who can get things done. But to get things done, you must love the doing, not the people!
    Reply With Quote  
     

  2. #2  
    Resident Grandpa marv's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Shell Knob, MO
    Posts
    3,036
    It's interesting to compare the Arab "weltanschauung" with what we see in the inner cities in the United States - such as Detroit or Chicago's Southside. In both instances, there are cultures with little interest in correcting an adverse, self created environment. Violence, and methods to violence, are the norm. Kill or be killed is the "weltanschauung", both figuratively and literally.

    I don't think there is a cure.

    http://members.socket.net/~mcruzan/images/allen-west.jpg

    Four boxes keep us free: the soap box, the ballot box, the jury box, and the cartridge box.

    THIS POST WILL BE MONITORED BY THE NSA
    Reply With Quote  
     

  3. #3  
    Power CUer noonwitch's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Warren, MI
    Posts
    12,997
    Quote Originally Posted by marv View Post
    It's interesting to compare the Arab "weltanschauung" with what we see in the inner cities in the United States - such as Detroit or Chicago's Southside. In both instances, there are cultures with little interest in correcting an adverse, self created environment. Violence, and methods to violence, are the norm. Kill or be killed is the "weltanschauung", both figuratively and literally.

    I don't think there is a cure.
    There are always those who get out of the ghettos in Detroit and other similar places-sometimes they get out because they are blessed with a particular talent, or because they have a parent or parents who keep them out of the violent culture. Some get educated and come back because they think they can help others do the same. Some end up star athletes and never look back.

    Dr. Ben Carson is a good example of someone of excellent quality to come out of the ghetto and return to help it's residents.

    In the arab world, there are no opportunities like here. The predominant religion offers no real hope or peace, and does not challenge the existing status quo. There is no alternative vision of life shown in their mass culture, at least outside of places like the US.
    Reply With Quote  
     

  4. #4  
    eeeevil Sith Admin SarasotaRepub's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2002
    Location
    Sunny,FL
    Posts
    43,594
    Hmmmm...interesting piece Ody.

    So to summarize, the Arabs are scum that can't be trusted and best case is to nuke them all.

    Works for me.
    May the FORCE be with you!
    Reply With Quote  
     

  5. #5  
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Posts
    3,269
    Quote Originally Posted by noonwitch View Post
    There are always those who get out of the ghettos in Detroit and other similar places-sometimes they get out because they are blessed with a particular talent, or because they have a parent or parents who keep them out of the violent culture. Some get educated and come back because they think they can help others do the same. Some end up star athletes and never look back.............
    Isn't it ironic that the worst ghetto in the U.S. still has the door open for anyone who has the will to leave? Some of those star athletes leave, all right. But most of the ghetto athletes will waste their lives slam dunking instead of doing homework, and athletic success never comes.

    NCAA grants 2500 football scholarships a year. NFL takes 250 of them. The average NFL career is 3 1/2 years long, and the average NFL player is dead broke 3 years after his last game. Basketball is similar, but I don't have the figures.

    Education paves the roadway out and locks the door behind, not athletics. But almost no one from the inner cities believes that.
    Reply With Quote  
     

  6. #6  
    Power CUer noonwitch's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Warren, MI
    Posts
    12,997
    Quote Originally Posted by Starbuck View Post
    Isn't it ironic that the worst ghetto in the U.S. still has the door open for anyone who has the will to leave? Some of those star athletes leave, all right. But most of the ghetto athletes will waste their lives slam dunking instead of doing homework, and athletic success never comes.

    NCAA grants 2500 football scholarships a year. NFL takes 250 of them. The average NFL career is 3 1/2 years long, and the average NFL player is dead broke 3 years after his last game. Basketball is similar, but I don't have the figures.

    Education paves the roadway out and locks the door behind, not athletics. But almost no one from the inner cities believes that.
    As long as NBA scouts attend DPS high school basketball games, the kids are going to dream big. But the occasional kid does make it out that way.

    Education is the key, that's why the example I used was Dr. Ben Carson.
    Reply With Quote  
     

  7. #7  
    Senior Member Janice's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2011
    Location
    Southern USA
    Posts
    2,809
    Quote Originally Posted by noonwitch View Post


    In the arab world, there are no opportunities like here. The predominant religion offers no real hope or peace, and does not challenge the existing status quo. There is no alternative vision of life shown in their mass culture ...
    Sounds a little like "the dream" 0bama has for the US.
    http://i1220.photobucket.com/albums/dd445/JansGraphix/ConsUndergrd-Sig2.jpg
    Liberalism is just communism sold by the drink.
    Reply With Quote  
     

  8. #8 Re: The 'Closed Circle' of the Arab 
    LTC Member Odysseus's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    FT Belvoir, VA
    Posts
    15,638
    Quote Originally Posted by Janice View Post
    Sounds a little like "the dream" 0bama has for the US.
    Pretty much. Scratch a liberal and you find a tyrant.
    Quote Originally Posted by Starbuck View Post
    Isn't it ironic that the worst ghetto in the U.S. still has the door open for anyone who has the will to leave? Some of those star athletes leave, all right. But most of the ghetto athletes will waste their lives slam dunking instead of doing homework, and athletic success never comes.

    NCAA grants 2500 football scholarships a year. NFL takes 250 of them. The average NFL career is 3 1/2 years long, and the average NFL player is dead broke 3 years after his last game. Basketball is similar, but I don't have the figures.

    Education paves the roadway out and locks the door behind, not athletics. But almost no one from the inner cities believes that.
    Unfortunately, the culture of the ghetto loathes education. It is considered a sellout to master school subjects, but aspiring to be an entertainer, an athlete or a criminal is accepted. The Arab culture has a similar hatred of labor, which is considered shameful. Both cultures emphasize longshots over far more reliable but less glamorous means of creating wealth, so both remain mired in poverty.

    Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
    --Odysseus
    Sic Hacer Pace, Para Bellum.

    Before you can do things for people, you must be the kind of man who can get things done. But to get things done, you must love the doing, not the people!
    Reply With Quote  
     

Bookmarks
Bookmarks
Posting Permissions
  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •